Federal Trucking Regulations in Texas: How Violations Strengthen Your Case
Federal trucking regulations in Texas set strict rules for drivers and carriers. Here is how a proven violation can strengthen your truck accident claim.

Federal trucking regulations in Texas exist for one reason: an 80,000-pound truck that is badly maintained, overloaded, or driven by someone who has not slept can kill people in seconds. Texas has more truck traffic than almost any other state, from I-35 and I-10 freight corridors to oilfield roads in the Permian Basin. When those rules are broken and someone gets hurt, the violation often becomes a central piece of the injured person’s case.
But the honest picture is more complicated than many law firm ads suggest. A violation does not automatically win a lawsuit. Since 2021, Texas House Bill 19 has limited when regulatory violations can be shown to a jury. In 2025, the Texas Supreme Court threw out a verdict of roughly $90 million against Werner Enterprises because the truck driver’s conduct was not a legal cause of the crash. Violations matter, but only when they connect to what actually happened.
This guide explains the FMCSA regulations that matter most, how Texas courts treat trucking violations, and what real enforcement cases show about falsified logbooks, ignored maintenance and unqualified drivers. It also covers the ethical side: how to build a Texas truck accident case on facts, not exaggeration. This article is general information, not legal advice. If you have been hurt, speak with a licensed Texas attorney about your specific situation.
Federal Trucking Regulations in Texas: The 7 Rules That Matter Most
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) writes the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, found in Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations. They apply to trucks moving freight across state lines. Texas adopts most of these rules for trucks operating only inside the state through Chapter 644 of the Texas Transportation Code and Chapter 4 of the Texas Administrative Code, with a few state-specific differences. The Texas Department of Public Safety enforces them on the road.
Here are the seven areas where violations most often show up in 18-wheeler accident cases.
1. Hours of Service Rules (49 CFR Part 395)
Fatigue is one of the most dangerous factors in truck crashes, which is why the hours of service rules are strict. For interstate property carriers, the main limits are:
- No more than 11 hours of driving after 10 consecutive hours off duty
- No driving beyond the 14th hour after coming on duty
- A 30-minute break after 8 cumulative hours of driving
- No driving after 60 hours on duty in 7 days, or 70 hours in 8 days
Texas intrastate drivers have somewhat longer limits under state rules, including up to 12 hours of driving. The full federal rules are summarized on the FMCSA hours of service page.
2. Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs)
Most interstate trucks must record duty status with an electronic logging device. ELD data shows when the truck moved, how long the driver drove, and whether records were edited afterward. In a crash case, that data can confirm or destroy a driver’s account of events.
3. Drug and Alcohol Testing (49 CFR Part 382)
Carriers must test drivers before hiring, randomly, after certain crashes and when there is reasonable suspicion. Since January 2020, carriers must also check the federal Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse to see whether a driver has prior violations. A carrier that skips these checks and puts an impaired driver behind the wheel faces serious exposure.
4. Driver Qualification (49 CFR Part 391)
Every carrier must keep a driver qualification file for each driver, including the application, past employer checks, driving record, road test certificate and a current medical certificate. Missing or fake records can support a claim that the company should never have let that person drive.
5. Commercial Driver’s License Rules (49 CFR Part 383)
Drivers need the correct CDL class and endorsements for the vehicle and cargo. Driving while disqualified or with a suspended license is both a violation and strong evidence in a negligent entrustment claim.
6. Inspection, Repair and Maintenance (49 CFR Part 396)
Carriers must inspect and maintain their trucks, keep maintenance records, complete annual inspections, and have drivers file post-trip inspection reports. Worn brakes, bad tires and broken lights are among the most common defects found after crashes.
7. Cargo Securement and Weight Limits (49 CFR Part 393)
Loose or overloaded cargo can shift, spill or cause rollovers. Cargo securement rules set requirements for tiedowns and load distribution, and Texas also enforces weight limits on its roads and bridges.
How Violations of Federal Trucking Regulations in Texas Strengthen Your Case
A rule violation is not a magic key. It is evidence, and like all evidence it has to connect to how the crash happened. Here is how violations actually work inside a Texas truck accident case.
Violations Can Show the Driver Was Careless
The basic claim in most truck crash cases is negligence: the driver or company failed to act with reasonable care. Proof that a driver was over the hours limit, had drugs in their system, or was driving with known brake defects can support the argument that they were not acting as a careful professional would. In some situations, Texas courts may also consider negligence per se, a doctrine that treats breaking a safety law as proof of negligence when the law was designed to prevent that kind of harm. Whether it applies to a given FMCSA rule depends on the rule and the facts, so this is a question for your lawyer.
Violations Can Expose the Trucking Company
Trucking companies are usually responsible for drivers acting within their job. Beyond that, violations can show the company itself was negligent:
- Negligent entrustment: letting someone drive who was unlicensed, disqualified or known to be unsafe
- Negligent hiring or retention: skipping background checks, Clearinghouse queries or required tests
- Negligent maintenance: ignoring repair needs or skipping inspections
- Pressure to break rules: dispatch schedules that can only be met by exceeding hours limits
House Bill 19 Changed the Rules of the Game
This is the part many articles leave out. Texas House Bill 19, effective for lawsuits filed on or after 1 September 2021, added a new subchapter to Chapter 72 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code. Its main effects:
- Bifurcated trial on request. If the defendant asks in time, the court must split the trial into two phases. Phase one decides liability and compensatory damages. Phase two deals with punitive (exemplary) damages.
- Limits on regulatory evidence in phase one. A defendant’s failure to follow a regulation is generally admissible in phase one only if it tends to prove the violation was a cause of the crash and meets other conditions in the statute.
- Specific exceptions. The law lists certain violations that can still come in during phase one for some claims, including key drug and alcohol testing rules and hours of service limits like 49 CFR 395.3, along with licensing and road test issues tied to negligent entrustment.
- Employer stipulation. If the company admits the driver was acting within the scope of employment, the plaintiff generally cannot also pursue certain ordinary negligence claims against the company in phase one.
In plain terms, a pile of unrelated safety violations will usually not reach the jury during phase one. A violation that helps explain the crash still can. Lawmakers have also filed bills since then to narrow these exceptions further, so the exact rules in force when your case is filed should be confirmed with a Texas attorney.
Causation Still Decides Cases: The Werner Lesson
The clearest recent example is Werner Enterprises v. Blake. After a 2014 crash on an icy Texas interstate, a pickup lost control, crossed a wide median and hit a Werner truck. A jury in 2018 found Werner and its driver largely responsible and awarded damages that grew to more than $100 million with interest. On 27 June 2025, the Texas Supreme Court reversed and dismissed the claims against Werner and its driver, holding that their conduct was not a proximate cause of the injuries.
The lesson is not that trucking companies always win. It is that the violation or careless act has to be tied to the crash itself. Strong cases show a clear chain from the broken rule to the harm.
Texas Deadlines and Fault Rules
Two more realities shape every case:
- Statute of limitations: Most Texas personal injury and wrongful death claims must be filed within two years.
- Proportionate responsibility: Texas reduces damages by the injured person’s share of fault, and a person found more than 50% responsible recovers nothing from the defendants.
Real Cases: What Past Trucking Violations Teach Us
The best way to understand why trucking violations matter is to look at real cases where companies or drivers broke the rules. These examples come from federal prosecutions and court records. Most did not happen in Texas, but the same federal rules apply on Texas highways.
Falsified Logbooks After a Fatal Crash (Rhode Island)
The owner of a Woonsocket, Rhode Island trucking company admitted to altering thousands of electronic log entries for about 20 drivers to hide how long they were actually driving and working. According to the DOT Office of Inspector General, the company’s drivers routinely exceeded driving and on-duty limits without taking required rest. After one of his drivers was involved in a fatal crash, the owner gave an FMCSA investigator altered hours-of-service records. In January 2021, he was sentenced to three years of probation, including six months of home confinement, after admitting the scheme in federal court. The U.S. Department of Justice press release describes the case.
What it shows: Older electronic recording systems allowed company officials to edit drive time. In a civil case, comparing ELD edit histories, fuel receipts, toll records and GPS data can reveal tampering.
Seven Motorcyclists Killed and a Falsified Log (Westfield Transport)
In June 2019, a truck from Westfield Transport, a Massachusetts company, collided with a group of motorcyclists in New Hampshire, killing seven. The driver was later acquitted of criminal charges, but federal investigators found the company’s owners had falsified driving logs in the weeks around the crash to evade federal rules. One co-owner was sentenced in 2024 to two months in prison for falsifying hours-of-service logs and lying to investigators.
What it shows: A driver can be found not criminally responsible while the company still faces consequences for its own record-keeping fraud. Civil claims can look at both.
A Fatal Crash on the Day of a Search Warrant (Nijjar Brothers)
In another federal case, DOT investigators said Nijjar Brothers routinely encouraged drivers to falsify logbooks. FMCSA tried its regulatory process first, then called in the Inspector General. On the day agents executed the first search warrant, one of the company’s drivers caused a four-vehicle collision that killed a father and his 13-year-old son.
What it shows: Patterns of falsified logs are often visible to regulators before a tragedy. In a lawsuit, a carrier’s prior compliance history and FMCSA reviews can help show the company knew about problems.
Systematic “Ghost Driver” Logs (McCord, Inc.)
In a federal case reviewed by the Eighth Circuit, DOT investigators found that McCord, Inc. had other people fill out driver logs, and that logs showed a fictional second driver on long trips to hide hours violations. A federal agent testified that about 1,600 logs falsely concealed violations. The company and its owner pleaded guilty.
Brake Failure and a Runaway Truck (Colorado, 2019)
In April 2019, a truck hauling lumber lost its brakes on I-70 near Denver and crashed into stopped traffic, killing four people. The young driver was convicted and initially sentenced to 110 years in prison, a sentence later reduced to 10 years by the governor after public outcry. The case sparked national debate about driver training, runaway truck ramps and how much responsibility falls on carriers that hire inexperienced drivers.
What it shows: Training, experience and maintenance records matter. Questions about who hired, trained and dispatched a driver are often as important as what the driver did in the final seconds.
The Common Thread
Across these cases, the same patterns appear:
- Hours were hidden to make deliveries faster
- Records were altered after something went wrong
- Regulators saw warning signs long before the crash
- The paper trail, not just eyewitnesses, revealed what happened
That is why a serious Texas truck accident investigation focuses on records, not just the crash scene.
Using Federal Trucking Regulations in Texas Ethically After a Crash
Knowing the rules is only useful if the evidence is preserved and the claim is built honestly. Here is how that works in practice.
What to Do After a Truck Accident in Texas
- Get medical care first. Some injuries, like brain trauma or internal bleeding, do not show symptoms right away. Medical records also link your injuries to the crash.
- Call the police and get the report number. In Texas, the crash report (CR-3) is often the first official record of what happened.
- Photograph everything if you safely can. Vehicles, skid marks, the truck’s DOT number, company name, trailer number, road conditions and your injuries.
- Collect witness names and phone numbers. Independent witnesses carry weight.
- Do not give a recorded statement to the trucking company’s insurer before talking to your own lawyer.
- Act quickly to preserve evidence. Some records can legally be discarded after a period, and electronic data can be overwritten.
Key Evidence That Proves Violations
A lawyer handling a truck case will usually send a spoliation letter soon after the crash, demanding that the company preserve evidence such as:
- ELD records and edit history
- Engine control module (“black box”) data showing speed, braking and throttle
- Driver qualification file and Clearinghouse queries
- Drug and alcohol test results
- Maintenance, inspection and repair records
- Dispatch messages, delivery schedules and pay records
- Dashcam and forward-facing camera footage
- Fuel, toll and GPS records that can be compared against logs
In Texas, destroying evidence after a duty to preserve it arises can lead to court sanctions, including instructions telling the jury it may presume the missing evidence was harmful to the party that lost it.
Public Records You Can Check
FMCSA’s public safety data, including a carrier’s inspection history, crash history and out-of-service rates, is available through its Safety Measurement System. A carrier with a long record of hours-of-service or maintenance violations may be easier to hold responsible for systemic problems.
The Ethical Line: Honest Claims Only
The same honesty demanded from trucking companies applies to injured people and their lawyers. Ethical realities to keep in mind:
- Never exaggerate injuries or invent symptoms. Insurers investigate claims closely, and insurance fraud is a crime in Texas. A dishonest claim can destroy a legitimate one.
- Do not stage or inflate accidents. Staged-crash rings targeting commercial trucks have led to federal prosecutions in other states, and they make it harder for real victims to be believed.
- Watch out for illegal solicitation. Texas treats paid case-running, known as barratry, as a crime, and it restricts how soon lawyers can contact accident victims. If someone calls you right after a crash offering a lawyer or a cash payment, be cautious.
- Choose a lawyer based on facts, not ads. Ask about trial experience, how they handle HB 19 issues, and how fees and costs work under a contingency agreement.
- Accept that not every crash is someone’s fault. As the Werner case showed, a tragic crash does not always mean the truck driver or company broke the law in a way that caused it.
Conclusion:
Federal trucking regulations in Texas can make a truck accident case much stronger, but only when a violation is proven with solid records and clearly connected to how the crash happened. Hours-of-service limits, ELD data, drug and alcohol testing, driver qualification files, CDL rules, maintenance records and cargo securement standards all create a paper trail, and real prosecutions of falsified logbooks in Rhode Island, Massachusetts and elsewhere show how often that trail reveals what companies tried to hide. At the same time, Texas House Bill 19 now limits when violations reach a jury, and the Texas Supreme Court’s 2025 reversal of the Werner verdict is a reminder that causation still decides outcomes.
Get medical care, preserve evidence quickly, stay honest about your injuries, keep the two-year filing deadline in mind, and work with a qualified Texas attorney who understands both the federal rules and how Texas courts apply them today.










